I've been using these for years and it's so hard to find them in retail for at least 2 yrs now. They come fresh, pack of 2, and I'm set for weeks. I mix the Enchantment shade with fuchsia, red, dark red, brown whatnot. Has a good texture and stays long. It does break a lot, and like 4mm of it falls out, but maybe that's for carrying it in my bag all the time, being shaken. I always keep one in my bag and one at home on my make up table. That one doesn't break.I’ve been using this liner for years! It’s amazing! Long wearing!ThanksSo glad I found this online ! I use this as my whole lip color - not just a liner. I like how I don't have to use a sharpener!Waxy and a bit to pink I was hoping more for mauveI have 3: work bag, purse and makeup drawer. I love the muted berry type color, I don't press hard and it's a slightly darker color than my lip. It pops but also blends when I add lipgloss.Will be buying again.Great easy to apply long lasting colorarrived today and i tested it out. within a few moments of using it, the end broke off. not too much product was lost and i put it back in the tube to use but it does make my life more difficult. this may have been my fault as i may have had it screwed up too high. as the nib is slanted. i maybe had it 2mm above the higher side. however, i would recommend this product as the pigment is good, arrived fast and is good for money but just make sure you don't apply too much pressure when using it or screwing it up too high.Easy to use & does not drag on lips….good colour will suit most shadesAlways use this ,long lasting and good valueCan't go wrong with the Rimmel lip liners, they have a great formula, high end expensive lip pencils are not necessary.Great