I purchased this with the Jolie eyeliner. I have tried numerous other sharpeners for my eyeliner pencils and had nothing but problems. The tip of the pencil would always clog up the sharpener or my eyeliner tip would break off as soon as I took it out of the sharpener thus wasting my eyeliner pencil. I saw other reviews on this sharpener and even though it looks just like any ordinary sharpener, it is superior! I have been able to use my entire eyeliner pencil without waste, it never clogged or broke of my tip. I am very pleased!