Decent lipliner. A bit drying IMO. The biggest downfall is that the picture is very misleading with regard to color. I realize screen displays are different. However, this is definitely not a nude lipliner. Its a very orangy-pink color. I was hoping for a more brown toned nude like the picture. If you are also...buyer beware!This was my first time ordering from this brand (Gerard). I went to the actual website and ordered additional make up products as well as ordering from Amazon. And I must say I was impressed with the quality, the packaging, and the price. The make up I ordered achieved exactly what I wanted it to achieve. I purchased the rose gold shimmery lipstick & placed it over the Nyx chocolate semi-Matte lip suede and it just popped! I suggest going to the website and see all the other yummy delicious products Gerard make up offers.Sometimes we have to step out of our comfort zone and try new things. If we don’t, how will we ever discover New and exciting looks that Work. S.R. Ridley, A Nurse You Can TrustIt is so creamy feeling and stays on great!This is a very good lip liner, application is smooth. The color is accurately portrayed. The only "problem" I find with this product is that it doesnt appear to be mechanical. I know it cannot be sharpened, so once the lip liner wears down, that's it?!..the pencil is not that inexpensive that I wouldn't mind the short use...because of this issue I gave it 4 stars.advertised as nude.Nude is not peach! it’s nude this pencil is peachI bought Ecstacy, and it's a true plum mauve. Not overly brown/salmon, and not a bold violet.Finally!Glides on smoothly and stays on. The color is beautiful !The only downfall is that is not an mechanical pencil. You need a sharpener.Works well with its sister lipstick. It's staying power is fine but not outstanding - this can be a good thing as the colour means it would be a dark line with no fill after a meal.Perfect just as described.